My guess is that very few writers on Substack can say they married one of their readers. Am I right?
Hang on… let me consult ChatGPT on that.
Bummer. Turns out AI has zero stats on writer-subscriber matrimony. But let’s just say this: I’ve never seen anyone write about this particular phenomenon. Have you?
Well, it happened to me. It’s actually a pretty cute story, so I figured it was finally time to spill it.
First, a brief preface: I have met so many wonderful men on Substack — fellow writers who are wired the right way, and avid readers who weigh in generously in the comments section. You know who you are… David, Armand, Tom, Sean, Steve, Jason, Greg, Robert, and so many others. I appreciate every single one of you. 💯
That said, this goes without saying — though I’m going to shout it from the rooftops anyway — I write for the thousands of incredible women who read my opinionated bullshit every month. Every piece is for YOU. I hope they make you laugh, cry, and blow steam out your ears.
The guys? They are just (hopefully) non-judgmental voyeurs on a stealth mission to understand how the female mind actually works.
I mean, seriously: what kind of guy is going to read anything emanating from a blog called Men On Pause — a publication explicitly devoted to taking a machete to misogyny and everyday sexist nonsense? My stuff can be a tough read for a guy, even (or especially) a really nice guy. So what kind of men read Men On Pause?
I’ll tell you who: men with DAUGHTERS.
About 90% of my male readers are girl-dads, from what I can ascertain. Then there’s the 9% who are genuinely trying to be better humans, and the remaining 1% who are useless, toxic assholes with severe DSB (I’ll let you guess what that stands for).
Overall, MOP’s male readers tend to be open-minded fellows. Men with empathy who not only understand what women have had to endure, but who appreciate why some of us are chronically crabby. They’re men who want the world to be a better place for women.
So, before I dive into the romance, let me state the obvious: many of you male readers are a total catch. You’re the GOOD GUYS. Decent people. And not surprisingly, almost all of you are happily married. Funny how that works… a guy is kind, hardworking, knows how to properly unload a dishwasher, is intimately familiar with the “equipment,” takes regular showers, and the gals tend to stick around. Who knew? Those qualities are pretty fucking sexy.
Now, back to my story.
A good long while ago, I decided I would never, ever date again. I made that vow after a wonderful, nearly 14-year relationship ended — sadly and abruptly. Out of respect for my previous partner, I will leave it at that. He was (and probably remains) a great guy; I was lucky to have had all those years with him, and I wish him only the best.
Marriage, however, had been off the table for even longer. Spending 18 years married to Satan, followed by 12+ years in court trying to extricate myself from his clutches — well, that was quite enough trauma for one lifetime. Thirty years of dealing with him. UGH. I was never taking a chance like that again. The silver lining from that three-decade ordeal was my two amazing kids. And yes, I’d endure him all over again if it meant getting those two.
A few years after my breakup with Mr. San Francisco (the good guy), I launched a freelance writing career, and Men On Pause came into being.
It was intoxicating and liberating to say out loud everything I had kept pent up for decades. Why the hell not? I had nothing left to lose. I was free. Free of demanding event clients, free of endless courtroom dramas with my ex, free of men, and my kids had officially flown the coop. There were no rules, no obligations, no expectations.
OMG, it was heaven.
After all those years of single motherhood, waking up each morning and doing whatever I wanted felt incredible. Life became blissfully uncomplicated; every decision I made was the right one by default. I lived in my designated “writing pajamas.” I abandoned makeup and hair dye. I took hour-long showers. I binge-watched Vera, cooked giant pots of soup, and ate it for dinner seven nights in a row. Whatever I felt like doing, I did.
Best of all, I could write and write, and say whatever the fuck I wanted. I could get up at 3:00 a.m. to bang out an essay, then take a nap at noon. I wrote at park picnic tables and in corner coffee shops. No one was interrupting a creative streak or demanding things from me when I was in the flow.
I wrote like a maniac — like someone who should have been writing her whole life. The stories just poured out. I was a brand-new person.
If you ever have the opportunity to check out from the world of obligations and expectations, do it. Even for a brief window of time. Don’t hesitate. When you return to reality, as we all inevitably must, you’ll know exactly who you are — and you’ll feel much more settled in your own skin.
Which brings me to John.
I was humming along, writing articles for various publications, doing the odd obituary, and developing my blogs (Men On Pause, Fictionalized, Red Light District, and Perp Church), when I crossed paths with him. 💕
Where I live, everyone knows John. And I do mean everyone. He’s a popular local politician who’s served our community for decades — a bona fide local celebrity.
One day, I needed to fact-check an article I was writing on wedding venues, and John was the guy with the answers — as Commissioner of Civil Marriages, which is just one of the many hats he wears. We had a quick email exchange; my questions were resolved instantly, and in the process of my research, I happened to spot a glitch on the county website related to outdated, post-COVID marriage license rules. I flagged the error for him as a courtesy.
Shortly after that exchange, I noticed that a new subscriber — bearing the exact same name as the Commissioner — had been reading Men On Pause and had dropped a very generous donation into the tip jar.
Not only that, but he was leaving wonderfully flattering comments on one of my most popular (and brutal) essays: “Are You A Nurse, Or A Purse?” That particular piece cast a pretty dim light on the dating scene for women over 60. A fragile man might have clutched his chicken nuggets and imagined the whole piece a personal insult. Not John. He loved it.
So when he asked me out for lunch — supposedly as a professional “thank you” for finding that glitch on the county website (riiiiight) — I felt pretty confident he could handle a gal with big opinions. Namely, me.
Fast forward: John became my biggest fan, my muse, and my favorite in-house editor (thanks to that master’s in literature from Berkeley). We share a mutual love for books and poetry, a healthy streak of intellectual snobbery, and a parallel life history as the unrepentant class clowns. To this day, neither of us has grown up or stopped playing the part of Touchstone from As You Like It.
Eventually, John and I decided to move in together. That turned out to be pretty damn fun, which led us to concoct the ultimate prank: getting married in his office, by his own staff.
The sting was simple. I walked into the clerk’s office unannounced, filled out a marriage license application at the counter, and asked the staff to summon the Commissioner to sign off on it. We hadn’t breathed a word to anyone in the office beforehand, so having his unsuspecting staff suddenly perform the ceremony and sign as witnesses was an absolute riot.
The best part? On our official marriage certificate, John’s name appears on the line for the Groom — and right down in the bottom-right corner, embossed with the county seal, his name appears a second time as the Issuing Officer. 😂
Talk about full-service government bureaucracy.
So to any of you Substack ladies worried that writing unfiltered, crabby feminist essays will ruin your romantic prospects: take heart. You just might end up marrying your biggest fan — who also happens to be the funniest guy in town, and pretty damn good-looking for an old cowboy. 😍




Hearty congrats. I like to think I'm Robert...
I love this so much!